top of page

Opening A Love For Lifelong Learning: A Dog Training Lesson From A Pickle Jar Lid

Pickle jar dog training analogy

We often resort to a few well-known approaches to opening a challenging pickle jar lid: using hot water to warm it up, using a tool like a silicone pad, forcefully denting the lid, or passing it around to different people. Surprisingly, the stubborn pickle jar holds a valuable lesson for dog training. Waiting for the tap to warm, and then taking time to run hot water over the lid while the metal expands is slow, however once you replace the jar in the refrigerator the seal returns to normal, the bond preserved. Conversely denting the lid is fast and works quite well to open it, but the lid will never be the same, the bond is degraded. Just like opening that stubborn jar, taking a gentler, longer term approach that protects the bond between you and your dog can foster a love for lifelong learning and dog training, and create remarkable growth. Embracing a positive, patient, and partnership-based approach can transform your canine companion's journey.

The Power of Positive Reinforcement: The Gentle Approach

Positive reinforcement involves luring or capturing when your dog does something right. By focusing on the positive aspects of your dog's actions, you create an environment where learning becomes enjoyable and rewarding.

Many studies have proven the efficacy of positive approaches over negative. A study published in the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis found that students were more engaged in learning tasks when positive reinforcement was provided compared to when it was not. Research published in the Journal of Educational Psychology found that students who received positive reinforcement for their efforts showed greater improvement in academic achievement compared to those who did not receive reinforcement. A meta-analysis published in the Review of Educational Research found that positive reinforcement strategies, such as praise and rewards, were associated with better retention of learned material over time. A study published in the Journal of School Psychology found that students who received positive reinforcement for appropriate behavior showed a decrease in problem behavior compared to those who did not receive reinforcement. Research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that individuals who received positive feedback experienced enhanced self-esteem and were more likely to engage in subsequent learning tasks.

Patience and Persistence: Nurturing Learning

In both early schooling and dog training, patience and persistence are key. They are the warm water. Just as it takes time for the pickle jar lid to gradually loosen under the tap, your dog's progress may not happen overnight. It's important to remember that training is a journey, and incremental progress is a sign of growth. Stay consistent in your efforts and celebrate even the smallest victories. With patience and persistence, you can unlock your dog's learning potential and witness remarkable transformations. 

Unlocking Dog Training Success with the Right Equipment

Just as a silicone pad helps unlock tough lids on pickle jars without damaging the seal, using the right tools in dog training can make all the difference in moving things along quickly while also preserving the bond between you and your furry companion. Take, for example, the Gentle Leader head halter which is used by the training organization Guide Dogs For The Blind on all puppies. This tool ensures they don't learn to pull on the leash before they're taught proper leash manners, preventing strain on the bond between handler and dog. This is by far the favorite tool of the dog walkers at Citizen Hound.

Similarly, a lure stick or flirt pole serves as a non-food-based reinforcer for highly energetic or work or play driven dogs. Like a specialized tool for a specific task, these tools engage a dog's natural instincts and drives, making training more enjoyable and effective for both dog and owner.

Just as denting the lid of a pickle jar may temporarily open it but damage the seal over time, rushing through training or using improper tools can strain the relationship between you and your dog. By investing in the right tools and taking a patient, methodical approach, you can unlock your dog's full potential while maintaining a strong and lasting bond.

Partnership and Fresh Perspectives: Unlocking Training Breakthroughs

Training your dog is not a solo endeavor. Much like the pickle jar that can be effortlessly opened after passing it to another person, sometimes a fresh perspective can unlock training breakthroughs. Seeking guidance from professional trainers or involving the whole family or friends in the training process can bring new energy and insights. Embrace the power of partnership and be open to different approaches. 

In Citizen Hound’s daily off leash play groups our walkers double as jr. dog trainers, in order to build and maintain the behaviors we need to keep everything safe and prosocial. On numerous occasions, difficult cases that have required work over a longer term can burn out the responsible pack leader, with waning energy in their training efforts from fatigue. It’s common to find that after moving that dog to a different walker the new leader unlocks great leaps as easily as someone being handed a loosened lid. 

The Results Of Positive Reinforcement Methods Speak For Themselves 

When your dog enjoys the training process, they become more eager to participate and excel in future endeavors. Fostering a love for learning in your dog lays the foundation for a lifelong bond and remarkable growth. By using slow, positive reinforcement methods, over the long term you can reach far greater results, much like enjoying the more complex flavors brought about by pickling vegetables.


Featured Posts
Recent Posts
Search By Tags
Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square
bottom of page